Should Colon's 10 wins be taken away????

scottcarter · Aug 23, 2012

ok so here me out for a sec. Moneyball is working again in Oakland and the A's might be the biggest surprise on the season but Colon cheated and won 10 games. Those are 10 huge wins in their playoff drive. Shouldn't they be forfeited? I think you could make an argument that they should.

When an Olympian test positive for an illegal substance, they take away his/her medals right? Don't they also take away the medals for the whole team in the Olympics? If Lebron for example tested for steroids would the USA lose their gold?

@)

PatsFan1283 · Aug 23, 2012

scottcarter said:
ok so here me out for a sec. Moneyball is working again in Oakland and the A's might be the biggest surprise on the season but Colon cheated and won 10 games. Those are 10 huge wins in their playoff drive. Shouldn't they be forfeited? I think you could make an argument that they should.

When an Olympian test positive for an illegal substance, they take away his/her medals right? Don't they also take away the medals for the whole team in the Olympics? If Lebron for example tested for steroids would the USA lose their gold?

@)

lol no. For like a million reasons.

Soriano12 · Aug 23, 2012

scottcarter said:
ok so here me out for a sec. Moneyball is working again in Oakland and the A's might be the biggest surprise on the season but Colon cheated and won 10 games. Those are 10 huge wins in their playoff drive. Shouldn't they be forfeited? I think you could make an argument that they should.

Poor SF Giants, after forfeiting the games in which they played Melky Cabrera, they might have less wins overall than the Astros on the road

scottcarter · Aug 23, 2012

I know but because it was a pitcher I thought it was interesting is all

loomis41973 · Aug 23, 2012

Interesting concept for sure...would be sure to create a fire storm.

They take wins away from CFB teams for less.

scottcarter · Aug 23, 2012

and also, don't you think that the GM and trainers will be forced to make sure they are clean and not cheating. Even the player knowing that he could really screw shit up for his teammates might be less likely to cheat. Maybe not.

Doug · Aug 23, 2012

Why does this thread have Wilheim's photo next to it ?

Huckel · Aug 24, 2012

it would be nice i would def tell my book to fuck himself since i know for a fact ive faded him about 12 of his however many starts and got burned

5teamparlay · Aug 3, 2015

Congrats on career win 214 bartolo ○○○

Should Colon's 10 wins be taken away????

Search

scottcarter

Breaking News: MikeB not running for president

PatsFan1283

Member

Soriano12

Member

scottcarter

Breaking News: MikeB not running for president

loomis41973

New member

scottcarter

Breaking News: MikeB not running for president

Doug

Rx God

Huckel

New member

5teamparlay

Member

Forum statistics

Share this page