Broker Fees for managing a 401K

Search

Banned
Joined
Mar 31, 2012
Messages
982
Tokens
do you mean the fees the mutual fund charges to manage and invest the money? If so that's a tad high, typically most funds charge from .5% to 1%.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 6, 2006
Messages
1,287
Tokens
do you mean the fees the mutual fund charges to manage and invest the money? If so that's a tad high, typically most funds charge from .5% to 1%.

I asked him about fees and this is what he said: "Fees for the plan on a weighted basis are 1.5%."

I am meeting him tomorrow.
 

New member
Joined
Mar 26, 2006
Messages
4,468
Tokens
401K's are a joke. My company had one for 15 years and this year I did away with it.
 

Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
10,180
Tokens
My guy is taking 1.5% is that standard?


Hmm. Does he know your amount of funds going in (its often laddered based on asset amts , for most )? He said that over the phone (only reason I ask is u said ur meeting him another day, 1st meeting? )? Ask him for Track record , references - if he shys away , run like the wind.
 

Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
10,180
Tokens
Gauge his response re., track record -you'll know 'right away ' kind of thing ..:)
 

New member
Joined
Mar 26, 2006
Messages
4,468
Tokens
Told my guys to take their 401K money and roll it over to an IRA. Everyone of them cashed out. The companies that administer the plans will milk it dry. I told em to go fuck themselves.
 

New member
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
Messages
637
Tokens
rolling it over into an ira might be a good idea, you can go to ameritrade/etrade/etc and just stick it in bonds/s&p 500 (spy)/etc without any fees

the 401k managers are usually going to underperform the s&p 500 AND take fees in doing so, over time that 1.5% is going to amount to a lot of money
 

New member
Joined
Mar 26, 2006
Messages
4,468
Tokens
Some of my guys were in a no risk fund, kinda like a savings/money market fund and they were getting a negative return. I called em up and said wtf? They said the fund was earning around 1% but after their fees it was like -1%. They were losing 1% by keeping their money in a no risk fund. That's when I called em up and told them to go screw themselves.
 

Rx Senior
Joined
Dec 7, 2004
Messages
18,351
Tokens
Some companies pay for the broker fees of their qualified plan.

If you have a good advisor may be worth staying with them....especially cause they hopefully avoid the bulk of disasters when shit hits the fan...maybe if you like the rooftop method...just roll over 90% into an ira and mimic the advisor in your ira account.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
Some companies pay for the broker fees of their qualified plan.

If you have a good advisor may be worth staying with them....especially cause they hopefully avoid the bulk of disasters when shit hits the fan...maybe if you like the rooftop method...just roll over 90% into an ira and mimic the advisor in your ira account.

This isn't true from my experience at all. Most managers (even "good ones") do just as bad when pigs are led to slaughter as everyone else, especially in the Mutual Fund industry. Most mutual fund managers aren't very knowledgeable when it comes to macroeconomics, especially on a global scale which is what we have today.

What they are good at is assessing a company's business environment and then through fundamental valuation assessing if a stock is undervalued.

As far as advisors, most know nothing besides being good salesmen. If they truly knew anything, they would know selling people load funds with 1.5% fees is like referring them to a bookie with -120 juice.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
Some of my guys were in a no risk fund, kinda like a savings/money market fund and they were getting a negative return. I called em up and said wtf? They said the fund was earning around 1% but after their fees it was like -1%. They were losing 1% by keeping their money in a no risk fund. That's when I called em up and told them to go screw themselves.

Yeah that is awful obviously.

Roof, your company fairly small? If they tried that on an institution/bigger business/gov't 403b plan they would get fired fast for it. No way that would fly.

A lot of charlatans out there.
 

Rx Senior
Joined
Dec 7, 2004
Messages
18,351
Tokens
This isn't true from my experience at all. Most managers (even "good ones") do just as bad when pigs are led to slaughter as everyone else, especially in the Mutual Fund industry. Most mutual fund managers aren't very knowledgeable when it comes to macroeconomics, especially on a global scale which is what we have today.

What they are good at is assessing a company's business environment and then through fundamental valuation assessing if a stock is undervalued.

As far as advisors, most know nothing besides being good salesman. If they truly knew anything, they would know selling people load funds with 1.5% fees is like referring them to a bookie with -120 juice.


I guess i don't have much experience with different advisors. The company i'm with pays for 95% or so of the broker fees. (I think the amount that gets charged to the employees is a flat $75/quarter or $300/year). They are actually not at all salesmen. We used to have the option of Morgan Stanley or Merrill Lynch (which were both salesmen type advisors) and switched about 5 years ago to our current guys. Current guys are a small group that actually do not hold the money, they keep it in Schwab and both we and they have access to move the money around. They have been very good at predicting the market on the whole and moving funds to less risk (no load) type funds when they feel uncertainty in the near future (i.e. around election time they tend to ease off on the risk with the uncertainty).

The bigger problem I have with the bigger brokerage firms is that they try to push their own funds. Which can be good but can be bad. I just don't like the limited options they are allowing your money to be invested in.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
I guess i don't have much experience with different advisors. The company i'm with pays for 95% or so of the broker fees. (I think the amount that gets charged to the employees is a flat $75/quarter or $300/year). They are actually not at all salesmen. We used to have the option of Morgan Stanley or Merrill Lynch (which were both salesmen type advisors) and switched about 5 years ago to our current guys. They have been very good at predicting the market on the whole and moving funds to less risk (no load) type funds when they feel uncertainty in the near future (i.e. around election time they tend to ease off on the risk with the uncertainty).

The bigger problem I have with the bigger brokerage firms is that they try to push their own funds. Which can be good but can be bad. I just don't like the limited options they are allowing your money to be invested in.

Yeah that is a problem with bigger brokerage firms (Fidelity is the biggest culprit for this)

Advisors of 401k/403b trying to time the market is something I haven't heard much of, potentially disastrous as well given whats at stake.

The problem with a lot of these 401k plans are the options are so limited, why opening a SDB and then just buying mutual funds through there is best for people that can actually pick superior funds (I know this seems hard but if you just go low expense ratio/dividend concentrated/no load you will do better than 90% of people) This is if 401/403 allow it but most do now.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
4,296
Tokens
i sat down with about eight advisors and they were all salesman..wanting between 1.1 to 1.5 percent...

a few weeks back i sent some money to vanguard.com they rates are .25 on most of their products.......gl

so far i like vanguard does anyone else use them???
 

Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
10,180
Tokens
One could argue , why even use an advisor/broker ? Very individualistic. As others have pointed out that 1.5% adds up Bigtime . Some don't have the 'knowledge' to care of it (even with passive investing ), not comfy . Okay . Let an 'expert ' take care of it. Just do ur homework. With that said , this profession's usefulness dramatically increases with rise of assets for the investor . To have large funds and not use an advisor? Nuts . Privy to investment vehicles you cannot get thru a discount brokerage firm (ex , debenture offerings , etc).


Like any profession there's good , not so good , bad...
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
2,773
Tokens
i sat down with about eight advisors and they were all salesman..wanting between 1.1 to 1.5 percent...

a few weeks back i sent some money to vanguard.com they rates are .25 on most of their products.......gl

so far i like vanguard does anyone else use them???


VANGUARD

VANGUARD

VANGUARD

i don't use them, but i own some of their products.

their products are top notch and the fees are some of the lowest in the industry.

i'm totally DIY on all my investments.

using an adviser is like having a post up account with an offshore book that charges you a % on your balance while at the same time charging you juice on the games.

go to the vanguard website, research and find a fund that has a low expense ratio and also fits your risk tolerance. I think they'll let you roll over any IRA, 401k to them and you can manage it yourself.

my advise is to find one fund and stick to it, no reason to buy multiple funds

vwinx is a nice one

good luck
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,108,132
Messages
13,448,718
Members
99,396
Latest member
depolarizados
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com