Which players to keep in Keeper league

CHOPTALK · Aug 24, 2013

Im in a keeper league where you can keep up to 3 players from the year before.

My team from last season is basically loaded.

A Morris
T Richardson
L Fitzgerald
D Thomas
Peyton Manning
C Johnson
To name a few.

I am keeping A Morris and Richardson for sure.

But the 3rd guy is tough.

L Fitzgerald with new QB
D Thomas (stud)
C Johnson (could be stud)

All 3 are projected 1st or 2nds so whoever I drop will probably be the first few picks of the draft.

What do you think?

Standard scoring
2 rb 3 WR 1TE 1 Flex

HarryCaray · Aug 24, 2013

Tough call but I keep Fitz, think he has a good bounce back year. Thomas close 2nd, and I just don't trust CJ anymore...

JMO

PatsFanatic · Aug 24, 2013

Id keep Fitzgerald.

I'm keeping a WR (Green) in my keeper league. But we only keep one. Keeping him over Morris (Its a PPR league)

PatsFanatic · Aug 24, 2013

BTW...I have Manning as well. QB's a dime a dozen for sure.

My draft is tonight at my office. Can't wait.

ZJP6050 · Aug 24, 2013

peyton, morris, tret

CHOPTALK · Aug 24, 2013

Fitz is the one I know Im supposed to keep but he basically cost me 1st place last season.
Thomas was a monster last year.
Would hate to cut the guy he did me so much good last season and keep the one that hurt me.

And there are still idiots out there drafting Johnson in the 1st round.
So I am basically letting a 1st rounder go that someone is going to be able to draft in the 4th round.
Our draft starts on the 4th round with the 1st 3 rounds being keepers.

I think I played Johnson 4 times last season.
Once I picked up Morris I was done with that plug.
I wish I could trade keepers before the draft.

CHOPTALK · Aug 24, 2013

Im going to drop Manning and hopefully get him with my first pick.

I will draft either Fitz/Thomas(whichever one I drop)or Manning with my first pick if Fitz/Thomas is gone.

I have 3 players im going to drop that will probably be the 1st 3 picks of the draft. LOL

HarryCaray · Aug 24, 2013

CHOPTALK said:
Fitz is the one I know Im supposed to keep but he basically cost me 1st place last season.
Thomas was a monster last year.
Would hate to cut the guy he did me so much good last season and keep the one that hurt me.

And there are still idiots out there drafting Johnson in the 1st round.
So I am basically letting a 1st rounder go that someone is going to be able to draft in the 4th round.
Our draft starts on the 4th round with the 1st 3 rounds being keepers.

I think I played Johnson 4 times last season.
Once I picked up Morris I was done with that plug.
I wish I could trade keepers before the draft.

Why can't you trade keepers? Just come to an agreement before the draft; keeper for keeper or your keeper for a combo if his draft picks...

CHOPTALK · Aug 24, 2013

dont know
Which I could trade Johnson trade value far higher then his worth.

jesse1111 · Aug 24, 2013

Other team has Doug Martin, Ray Rice, Ridley, Jimmy Graham, and Marshawn Lynch to narrow it down from. Mine was easy only 1 player worth keeping.

FairWarning · Aug 24, 2013

Why would you want to draft Manning 1st Chop? QB's are easy to find and you can only start one. I would rather have another stud RB/WR and draft a QB like Carson Palmer, Luck, Wilson, Roethlisberger, later.

CHOPTALK · Aug 24, 2013

FairWarning said:
Why would you want to draft Manning 1st Chop? QB's are easy to find and you can only start one. I would rather have another stud RB/WR and draft a QB like Carson Palmer, Luck, Wilson, Roethlisberger, later.

Well the 1st pick is actually the 4th round.

The first 3 rounds are your keepers so its not really a true 1st round.

CHOPTALK · Aug 24, 2013

jesse1111 said:
Other team has Doug Martin, Ray Rice, Ridley, Jimmy Graham, and Marshawn Lynch to narrow it down from. Mine was easy only 1 player worth keeping.

I did not realize you were in the league.
Which team are you?

Heck I might get to draft Graham with my first pick with all that guy has.

That would be awesome.

CHOPTALK · Aug 24, 2013

Against my better judgement I just dropped Thomas and kept Fitzgerald.

Only due to this thread.
I hope I made the right move.

gatorbait08 · Aug 24, 2013

Not in all leagues, I'm in a two qb league and they go fast.

jesse1111 · Aug 25, 2013

He Hate Me. Came in second first year. Didn't make the draft last year and had 1 win and I think that was the last game of the year.

Which players to keep in Keeper league

Search

CHOPTALK

Member

HarryCaray

EV Whore

PatsFanatic

Member

PatsFanatic

Member

ZJP6050

Member

CHOPTALK

Member

CHOPTALK

Member

HarryCaray

EV Whore

CHOPTALK

Member

jesse1111

New member

FairWarning

Official Rx music critic and beer snob

CHOPTALK

Member

CHOPTALK

Member

CHOPTALK

Member

gatorbait08

Member

jesse1111

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page