Which Team Would You Rather Have? Settling an argument..

ParlaysStoleMyMoney

Member

Joined

Jan 12, 2008

Messages

2,196

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #1

Not at the beginning of the season, right NOW. Taking into account injuries and how they effect players on each team. Taking into account players who weren't well known but have performed so far this year, etc. etc. Thoughts?

Fantasy Team 1:

Starters:
Peyton Manning
Anquan Boldin
Alshon Jeffery
CJ Spiller
Chris Ogbonnaya
Jordan Reed
Jerome Simpson
Stevie Johnson
Adam Vinatieri
Chiefs

BENCH:
Ben Tate
Ted Ginn
Rashard Mendenhall
Darren McFadden
Jarret Boykin




TEAM 2:
Matthew Stafford
Andre Johnson
Wes Welker
Jamaal Charles
Fred Jackson
Jeff Cumberland
Josh Gordon
Harry Douglas
Mason Crosby
Texans

Bench:
Danny Amendola
Willis Mcgaee
David Wilson
Rashad Jennings
Chris Ivory

 

ParlaysStoleMyMoney

Member

Joined

Jan 12, 2008

Messages

2,196

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #2

Should also say pretty standard scoring and it is PPR. 12 teams in the league.

Starting rosters look like this:QB, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, WRT, WRT, K, Defense.

 

Defying

Member

Joined

Feb 10, 2009

Messages

17,706

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #3

not even close really, Team 2 for me

 

Jstack34

Member

Joined

Oct 18, 2008

Messages

8,332

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #4

Team 2 IMO

 

Stax

New member

Joined

Nov 17, 2011

Messages

2,170

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #5

Team 2 no doubt

 

celticGreen+

New member

Joined

May 20, 2007

Messages

6,559

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #6

Agree, team 2 and not even close.

 

SharkTank

New member

Joined

Aug 2, 2013

Messages

317

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #7

team 2 for sure

 

JasonBiggz

New member

Joined

Mar 22, 2010

Messages

469

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #8

Definitely Team 2.

 

HarryCaray

EV Whore

Joined

Apr 18, 2006

Messages

19,916

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #9

Add another vote for team 2

 

Defying

Member

Joined

Feb 10, 2009

Messages

17,706

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #10

is that not the answer you wanted lol

 

CHOPTALK

Member

Handicapper

Joined

Oct 31, 2004

Messages

44,302

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #11

In real football team 1
In fake football team 2

 

ParlaysStoleMyMoney

Member

Joined

Jan 12, 2008

Messages

2,196

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #12

Defying said:

is that not the answer you wanted lol

Click to expand...

I don't want to say anything until everyone that wants to gets a chance to vote.

 

loomis41973

New member

Joined

Dec 16, 2011

Messages

13,268

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #13

1

 

Porcupine

New member

Joined

Sep 18, 2005

Messages

1,266

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #14

Another for team 2

 

slapshot

Member

Joined

Sep 21, 2004

Messages

19,208

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #15

1

 

michael777

Member

Joined

Sep 21, 2004

Messages

14,237

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #16

1

 

HarryCaray

EV Whore

Joined

Apr 18, 2006

Messages

19,916

Tokens

• Oct 20, 2013

• #17

HarryCaray said:

Add another vote for team 2

Click to expand...

I will add I don't think it's a complete no-brain slam dunk winner. I'd take 2 but not by like 20 miles or something. Fairly comparable teams with 2 being slightly better IMO.