Could you find a permanant spot on your roster for these football players?

NFLTrends · Jul 3, 2014

A Running back, who, no matter what, gains 1 yard.... no more and no less, every time he runs the ball. He cant catch, and cant block, and cant throw. He can only run for 1 yard.

A Kicker who is guaranteed to make exactly the first 3 (and only 3, no more and no less) 60yd or more field goal kicks, then never make another till the start of the next season.... but will only make 66% of those 59yds or less the whole season. BUT will make 100% of extra points

HarryCaray · Jul 3, 2014

#1 absolutely

#2 not so sure

loomis41973 · Jul 3, 2014

1 yes

2 no

shdw01 · Jul 3, 2014

Yes to both...esp when extra points become 20+ yds

slapshot · Jul 3, 2014

1 no2 yes

Defying · Jul 3, 2014

yes, since I know 100%.. I save the kicker for game winning kicks.... and the running back when there is less than a yard to go, every single 4th n less than 1 I go, since I know 100% what to expect.

HarryCaray · Jul 3, 2014

Defying said:
yes, since I know 100%.. I save the kicker for game winning kicks.... and the running back when there is less than a yard to go, every single 4th n less than 1 I go, since I know 100% what to expect.

It would open up your game so much more. 3rd and 1 you could just throw a deep route every time, come back and pick it up on 4th.

Also goal line is an automatic score.

Soriano12 · Jul 3, 2014

HarryCaray said:
Also goal line is an automatic score.

just imagine the deadly 1-2-punch he would make with your WR that won't make a single catch all season, but draws a PI on his defender every time he's targeted in the endzone...

HarryCaray · Jul 3, 2014

Soriano12 said:
just imagine the deadly 1-2-punch he would make with your WR that won't make a single catch all season, but draws a PI on his defender every time he's targeted in the endzone...

LOL good point Sori

Soriano12 · Jul 4, 2014

Too me both would be a no brainer: A short yardage specialist that gives me a guaranteed 1yard in those situation should have lots of value.
Plus I'd just carry two kickers on my roster: I get every single PAT, 3 guaranteed 60+ FGs (so getting to midfield in a game I trail by max. 2pts would already be enough to win it....) and 66% from 50-59yards out...that might already be pro bowl material. And for any additional 60+ FG attempt or anything closer than 50 I just bring in "the other guy"...

Mr_Mark · Jul 4, 2014

Soriano12 said:
Too me both would be a no brainer: A short yardage specialist that gives me a guaranteed 1yard in those situation should have lots of value.
Plus I'd just carry two kickers on my roster: I get every single PAT, 3 guaranteed 60+ FGs (so getting to midfield in a game I trail by max. 2pts would already be enough to win it....) and 66% from 50-59yards out...that might already be pro bowl material. And for any additional 60+ FG attempt or anything closer than 50 I just bring in "the other guy"...

FairWarning · Jul 4, 2014

John Kuhn for Green Bay is that type of player who will get you a yard.

seanjohn007 · Jul 4, 2014

I saw yes to both, especially the first one. 1st and goal on the 4 is a guaranteed touchdown, not to mention goal line situations like above

Could you find a permanant spot on your roster for these football players?

Search

NFLTrends

New member

HarryCaray

EV Whore

loomis41973

New member

shdw01

Rx Senior

slapshot

Member

Defying

Member

HarryCaray

EV Whore

Soriano12

Member

HarryCaray

EV Whore

Soriano12

Member

Mr_Mark

Member

FairWarning

Official Rx music critic and beer snob

seanjohn007

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page