Who would you rather have Jimmy Graham or Calvin Johnson?

CHOPTALK · Aug 25, 2014

Real football not fantasy football.

betmonkey · Aug 25, 2014

Graham. I just think it's harder to find a great TE than a great WR. Plus Graham plays a lot out of his position at slot...etc A year younger doesn't hurt either.

AND...he was born the same place as me...lol

I was looking at their current salaries and it is a shame. They should get MLB money

NickPappagiorgio · Aug 25, 2014

Calvin Johnson and its not even close

Acebb · Aug 25, 2014

NickPappagiorgio said:
Calvin Johnson and its not even close

+1

It is a laughable question.

Look at how Jimmy did against the best team in football last year - 4 catches - and you get your answer.

CHOPTALK · Aug 25, 2014

I'm glad ace thinks its laughable.
He is one of those people you always want to be opposite of as much as possible.

Saying it's not even close is laughable

Defying · Aug 25, 2014

I take Calvin Johnson

LoCalDallasGuy · Aug 25, 2014

Yeah, They are both a beast but I think you have to go with CJ here.

Shub · Aug 25, 2014

It's not laughable to pose the question but imagine cj on the saints with brees. It's really a close call but I would take cj.

slapshot · Aug 25, 2014

PatsFanatic · Aug 25, 2014

I think if Graham was a better blocker than I would choose him. But since he's strictly a pass catching TE than I would go with Megatron.

SwiftyJ · Aug 25, 2014

PatsFanatic said:
I think if Graham was a better blocker than I would choose him. But since he's strictly a pass catching TE than I would go with Megatron.

this

HuskerFan1 · Aug 25, 2014

i thought this was a fantasy football question

OneZero · Aug 25, 2014

HuskerFan1 said:
i thought this was a fantasy football question

either way, the answer is Calvin.

shdw01 · Aug 25, 2014

In ff I take graham....in real football megatron

shdw01 · Aug 25, 2014

Getting wr production out of the te spot is huge in ff...esp consistent elite production.

CaPPiNgTiGeRz · Aug 25, 2014

As much as i love Jimmy and fact that he is a Saint and i am a monster Saints fan i still have to say i would go with Megatron non-fantasy wise. He is just such a monster out there.

FairWarning · Aug 25, 2014

Jimmy Graham is a WR (and putting up elite WR numbers) playing the TE spot.

JustinCruise · Aug 25, 2014

NickPappagiorgio said:
Calvin Johnson and its not even close

Have to agree

Vlad the Impaler · Aug 25, 2014

NickPappagiorgio said:
Calvin Johnson and its not even close

Eaxactly. Are you kidding me. Tight ends are a dime a dozen. Peyton made Jacob Tamme look legit and this new guy in Denver as well. Calvin Jonhson every time and in real life, I take him over Peterson. When you have a great receiver who can catch and create seperation, that is rare. With a great QB throwing to them, they are great. What would Marvin Harrison look like if Donovan McNabb was his qb. Just average

And you could get a 1,000 yard rusher with a great QB in the 6th round

loomis41973 · Aug 25, 2014

CJ every day.

Saying it IS close is laughable.

ointer:

Who would you rather have Jimmy Graham or Calvin Johnson?

Member

New member

New member

Member

Member

Member

New member

Member

Member

Member

New member

Member

New member

Rx Senior

Rx Senior

New member

Official Rx music critic and beer snob

New member

Banned

New member

Forum statistics

Share this page